I topped off with a bit too much water, so I think I diluted mine, but in general I'm very pleased. Nice color, pleasing aroma and a well balanced flavor. I think it could have had some more punch if I hadn't added too much water. I would have liked it more if it had a bit more aroma and bite. Even though the recipe is called Simcoe Pale Ale, AHS includes some Cascade hops for aroma (which surprised me). If I made this again, I'd dry hop it with more Cascades or Simcoe (or both). Overall: recommended!
Reviewed by: Old Site Reviewer from United States.